It’s Complicated
Before I was elected, and before I had read anything useful like I hope this book will be, I tried to understand the pension situation in Encinitas. Residents were raising alarms about unfunded pension liabilities and elected Council members were trying to reassure everyone that the situation was under control. I kept hearing “it’s complicated,” which felt like a patronizing pat on the head, like my little female brain wasn’t capable of understanding the issue.
After I was elected, I was able to dig in deeper and, guess what: it was complicated! I found myself on this, and other issues, wanting to tell constituents, “it’s complicated” quite often. Instead, I started writing a weekly newsletter to help them understand. Not everyone wants to get into the weeds, but if there is trust that information coming from public officials is honest and accurate, people can more easily accept an outcome, even if they don’t completely understand all the details.
Regarding pensions, there was reason to be concerned, but the problem was not as extreme as some portrayed it. And some steps were being taken to address it. I proposed, and the Council agreed, to some additional measures and I believe the city is in good financial shape and acting responsibly regarding pensions.
But it is emblematic of much more pervasive problems these days – people want simple solutions to complicated problems. It’s hard to accept that your (often well-intentioned but misinformed) ideas won’t work. Often there are laws, like it or not, limiting what is possible. Often there are other perspectives that we had not considered – the infamous unintended consequences. Even in relatively small communities, there is a need for professional experts to assist in developing public policies.
Engaged citizens may think deeply and have strong opinions on issues ranging from public finance, transportation, housing, climate action, water management, or even recreation. Policymakers need to listen to residents and understand their needs and desires. That input must also be integrated with guidance from the technical experts, and with luck, good decisions will result.
And yet it is unlikely that anyone will be happy with every decision that is made and every policy outcome. Sometimes, if their ideas are not implemented, their egos are hurt, and they feel unheard. But the real reason is because … it’s complicated.